Search
Close this search box.
PFlag Icon

ABOUT US

Our team

Serving Christ and Our Community

The Presbyterian Church in Morristown is led by committed members and professionals who believe in serving Christ and the community at large.

Vigilante_Daniel staff page

Pastor

Rev. Daniel Vigilante

Rev. Daniel Vigilante is a lifelong Presbyterian – and the grandson of a Presbyterian pastor. He grew up in Morris Plains and graduated from Morristown High School in 1995. Discerning a call to ministry from an early age, he went straight to seminary after college, earning a Master of Divinity from Princeton Theological Seminary in 2004. He is currently working toward his Doctor of Ministry at Duke Divinity School. He has served congregations in New Jersey, California, and Minnesota.

Daniel has a heart for leading God’s people in worship that is engaging, approachable, and true to our Reformed tradition. His passion is to help churches grow in faith, in mission, and in number by reaching out and connecting with the community in new and dynamic ways – sharing the love of God in Jesus Christ in word and action.

When not in church, he loves to travel, hike, paint, read, cook, and snowboard. Daniel and his husband James are living in the manse here in Morristown and have two dogs named Freddie and Harry.

(973) 538-1776 Ext. 2015

Webber, Audrey_robe_5x5

Associate Pastor, Adult and Care Ministries

Rev. Audrey Webber

Rev. Audrey Webber (she/her) serves as the Associate Pastor, overseeing pastoral care and adult ministries. She is a cradle Presbyterian and has spent most of her life in New York City. She received her bachelor’s from Hunter College, double majoring in Religion and Art History, her MDiv from Princeton Theological Seminary, focusing on pastoral care, and is currently in the PhD program in Practical Theology at the University of Glasgow.

Being with people is her passion, especially in the context of the church, preferably over mac and cheese! She is also committed to using the arts and creative programming in her work. She has involved this creativity at PCM and her previous churches, including the First Presbyterian Church in the City of New York and her leadership in the NYC Presbytery.

In her free time, Audrey loves to create art, write, root on the Yankees, visit museums, watch TCM, and spend time with her husband, Woodie, and their children, Russell and Grace.

(973) 538-1776 Ext. 2017

Mead, Alexandra 2022_5x5

Director of Children, Youth, and Family Ministries

Alexandra Mead

Alexandra grew up in the Presbyterian Church of Morristown. She was baptized, educated, and then married here. She and her husband, David, have raised their three children at PCM.

Alexandra began directing the Christian Education programs at PCM in 2010. She leads our Sunday school, Midweek program, and Vacation Bible School, along with a bible study and special events for children and their parents.

Alexandra has served on the Board of Directors of Cornerstone Family Programs, The Junior League of Morristown, and the Garden Club of Morristown. Alexandra and David live in Mendham, where they enjoy renovating their 1906 Victorian home and working in their yard and garden.

(973) 538-1776 Ext. 2016

Tufts, Amanda_5x5

Director of Community Engagement

Amanda Tufts

Amanda’s favorite things to do is to bring people together (yes, she’s lookin’ at you!) She joined PCM in 2022,  focusing on the experience, connection, and engagement within and beyond the walls of the church. She graduated from Emerson College (Boston) with a Bachelor’s degree in Marketing Communications and from Saint Elizabeth University (Morristown) with a Master’s in Organizational Change Management.

On the weekend, you will find Amanda reading a good book, riding her motorcycle, planning her next trip to Ireland, or trying to get her husband AJ, their two kids and three dogs to stay still for a photo. Send help.

(973) 538-1776 Ext. 2021

CL

Youth Ministry Director

Caleigh Lawlor
Caleigh graduated from Elon University in May 2024 with degrees in Sport Management and Journalism and currently works as a Licensing Administrator with the sports apparel company, Fanatics. She grew up down the street in Randolph, and joined the the Presbyterian Church in Morristown when she was in elementary school. She was an active member in PCM’s music programs, including Ringers on the Green and Chancel Choir, attended youth group, and helped with childcare. Caleigh currently serves on the board for the annual mission trip the high school youth group attends, R.I.S.E, and has a passion for giving back to the communities that have helped shape her into the person she is today. She currently lives in Randolph, New Jersey, and can be found reading a book or catching a hockey or baseball game in her free time.

(973) 538-1776 Ext. 2021

Mueller, Jeanne 2024 (1)

Nursery School Director

Jeanne Mueller

Jeanne Mueller has been the Director of the PCM Nursery School since August 2015. She was a teacher at the school for ten years and a member of the Advisory Board. The Nursery School has six staff members teaching classes that provide an outstanding early childhood experience for children ages 2.5 years through age 5. Jeanne has two children, a daughter who is a teacher in Indianapolis and a son who is a 2023 graduate of the University of Oregon. Both of her children attended the Nursery School. Jeanne and her staff help to continue the level of excellence that has been established at the school.

Visit the Nursery School Website

(973) 540-1114 Ext. 2023

Koski, Paul 2022-5x5

Director of Administration

Paul Koski
Paul joined PCM in 2021 with a financial services background focused on operational improvement, business analysis, and business management. He holds a Bachelor of Engineering degree in Industrial Engineering from Stevens Institute of Technology. Paul is married with three adult children and lives in Ridgewood, NJ.

(973) 538-1776 Ext. 2014

Smith, Kay 2024 (1)

Administrative Assistant

Kay Smith

Kay is originally from Santa Barbara, CA and graduated with a BS in Education from Cal Poly San Luis Obispo. As a grad student there, she studied abroad in Morelia, Mexico and earned a Certificate of Proficiency in Spanish. She taught Elementary School in San Juan Bautista, CA and in Englewood, NJ before moving to Madison. She comes to us from Drew University where she spent fifteen years serving as the Executive Assistant to the Senior Vice President.

Kay now lives in Convent Station with her husband and has three grown children. She enjoys being outdoors, sports (especially playing pickleball), travel, reading and, of course, loves spending time with her three grandchildren.

office@pcmorristown.org

(973) 538-1776 Ext. 2010

Kevin McAllister

Financial Administrator

Kevin McAllister

Kevin McAllister joined the PCM team in January of 2025 as Financial Administrator. Kevin brings over 30 years of corporate finance experience in industries such as entertainment, consumer products, telecommunications, and maritime ports. His areas of expertise include financial planning & analysis, capital budgeting, budgeting & forecasting, and implementation of various corporate financial systems.

Kevin holds a Bachelor of Arts degree in Business Administration with a Concentration in Finance from The University of North Carolina at Charlotte as well as a Master of Business Administration (MBA) with concentrations in Finance and Accounting from Seton Hall University. Kevin also holds a certificate in Leadership from Penn State University.

Outside of work, Kevin enjoys vacationing at Disney or the South Carolina beaches, enjoying concerts and shows, and grilling at cookouts or tailgating. Kevin is an avid sports fan and roots for the New York Mets, Carolina Panthers, and New York Rangers. Kevin resides in Morristown with his wife Karen, their three children, and their dog Kuechly.

(973) 538-1776

Pango, Kristo_5x5

Senior Sexton

Kristo Pango

Kristo Pango joined the church staff as sexton at the Parish House in October 2013. He maintains the buildings and grounds and provides support at events and services. Kristo and his family came to the U.S. from Albania in 2008. He and his wife Argjiro have three children. In Albania, Kristo was a pastor at the Way of Hope Evangelical Baptist Church. He came to witness to fellow Albanians who now live in the New York and New Jersey area. He feels that working as a sexton at our church, in a Christian environment, will help him in his mission to reach out to others and plant churches in Albanian communities.

(973) 538-1776

Deacons

The ministry of the Board of Deacons is one of compassion, witness, service, and sharing in the redeeming love of Jesus Christ for the poor, the hungry, the sick, or anyone in distress. Our deacons, who serve a three-year term, work with the staff to provide pastoral care and outreach to members who are homebound or have other needs that call for special attention.

Session

An important part of Presbyterian tradition is to provide persons with particular gifts to share in discernment of God’s Spirit and governance of God’s people. The Session is comprised of those called into this ministry and elected as Elders. An Elder is a lay person charged with serving as an administrator or ordained to an office. They may also serve in preaching or pastoral roles. Together with the pastors, the Session governs the church, providing leadership, spiritual discernment, and guidance.